Anna Maria's Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

Anna Maria's Pizza offers a focused menu of classic and specialty pizzas, pasta dishes, and hearty Italian favorites. Sitting at 823 Gardner St in South Beloit, IL, they cater exclusively through carry-out and delivery, making your meal convenient and contactless. Their menu features generous cheese layers, flavorful toppings, and signature crusts prepared with care. Expect options like stuffed pizzas, lasagna, and a variety of pasta with red marinara, Alfredo, or meat sauce. Their popular menu items include rich, cheesy stuffed veggie pizzas and perfectly crispy garlic bread, touted by loyal customers as

Heavenly

the best stuffed pizza

delicious seafood

authentic Italian flavors.

Mains
Pasta
Sandwiches - All Served w/ Fries
Salads
Appetizers
Pizzas
Pan Pizzas
Stuffed Pizzas
Calzones
Anna Maria's Pizza Menu image 1
Anna Maria's Pizza Menu image 2
Anna Maria's Pizza

Anna Maria's Pizza Interior, Food, Ambiance

Although Anna Maria's Pizza operates solely through carry-out and delivery, their cozy, casual vibe shines through in every dish. Their kitchen crafts each pizza with care, ensuring a crisp crust and melted cheese. The atmosphere remains friendly and welcoming, echoing the warm community spirit of South Beloit. Expect flavors that remind you of family gatherings and neighborhood celebrations—without the dine-in fuss. Their spacious parking, accessible for wheelchairs, complements the quick, efficient service that gets hot food to your door or ready for pickup.

Loyal customers say it feels like visiting family, thanks to their friendly staff and consistent quality. Whether you’re picking up a late-night snack or ordering a hearty lunch, Anna Maria’s delivers the comfort of traditional Italian food, right in your own space.

Anna Maria's Pizza

About Anna Maria's Pizza Food and Specialties

Anna Maria's Pizza specializes in hearty, flavor-packed Italian-American cuisine made with local ingredients. Their stuffed pizzas are legendary, loaded with fresh vegetables, cheese, and a flavorful sauce. For pasta lovers, the lasagna and mostaccioli with Alfredo or marinara sauce deliver comfort in every bite. Customers rave about their rich, high-quality cheese and perfectly balanced sauces that keep them coming back. The restaurant also offers delicious seafood dishes like mussels, fried cod, and breaded shrimp, bringing a coastal touch to their menu. Their drinks menu complements the food with a great selection of beers, wines, cocktails, and coffee, building a complete food-and-drink experience.

Whether you're craving a quick lunch or a satisfying dinner, Anna Maria’s delivers flavorful, satisfying food fast, making them a neighborhood favorite for solo diners, groups, and tourists alike.

They serve locally renowned Italian dishes and comfort foods that celebrate genuine flavors. Their commitment to quality and fast service makes them stand out in South Beloit's vibrant food scene, especially appreciated by students from nearby Beloit College.

Anna Maria's Pizza

Anna Maria’s Pizza commits to delivering authentic Italian flavor with a local touch. Our specialty lies in perfecting our stuffed veggie pizza, breaking the mold of typical takeout fare, and offering hearty pastas like our signature lasagna. We believe quality ingredients, prompt service, and community spirit create a dining experience worth repeat visits. Our vision is to become the go-to source for comfort food and pizza in South Beloit while supporting local farmers and businesses.

We aim to expand our reputation for friendly service beyond to include catering and special event options. Accessibility and affordability remain at the core of our philosophy, ensuring everyone can enjoy a slice of Italy in Illinois. As we grow, we stay dedicated to core values—fresh ingredients, community engagement, and an unwavering commitment to excellent food and service.